The Best Places to Buy a Vacation Rental in 2027

—

by

STR Super Hosts

For three years the question about vacation rentals was whether the boom was over. Heading into 2027 the question has changed. Supply has nearly stopped growing, nightly rates are rising again, and the hosts who already own are winning. The hard part is buying well at today’s interest rates, and that changes which places make sense.

This guide replaces our 2024 market list. It pulls together the latest national data, AirDNA’s two 2026 market rankings, and our own read of more than 5,000 homes for sale that are marketed as short-term rentals. It ends with a shortlist of nature-based markets we think still work in 2027 and a simple test you can run on any address.

The 2027 picture in six numbers

  • 1.2%. Year-over-year growth in available U.S. short-term rental listings in October 2026, down from a 24.9% peak in February 2023.
  • 57.4%. AirDNA’s 2026 U.S. occupancy forecast, slightly above the pre-pandemic average of 57%.
  • +2.9%. Forecast 2026 growth in revenue per available rental, driven almost entirely by higher nightly rates.
  • 7.11%. The average 30-year mortgage rate on November 12, 2026, versus 6.24% a year earlier.
  • +35%. Growth in Airbnb searches for stays near U.S. national parks heading into 2026.
  • 323 million. National Park Service recreation visits in 2025, with 26 park units setting records.

Five forces shaping short-term rentals in 2027

1. Supply has become the bottleneck

New listings grew at more than 20% a year after the pandemic. By late 2026 that had collapsed to around 1 to 2%, as higher mortgage rates kept would-be buyers on the sidelines. AirDNA’s midyear outlook summed it up as a better year to own than to buy, and it expects demand, occupancy and pricing to strengthen through 2027. For owners that means less new competition. For buyers it means the best operators are holding, not selling.

2. Growth is coming from rate, not volume

Revenue gains in 2026 came mostly from average daily rate rather than more booked nights. AirDNA expects rate growth to accelerate in 2027. Properties that can justify a higher rate, through location, design, a view or an amenity, capture that growth. Commodity listings do not.

3. The cost of money is the real filter

With 30-year rates above 7% and investor loans priced higher still, the purchase price relative to revenue matters more than ever. That is why both of AirDNA’s 2026 rankings were led by affordable workforce and mid-size markets rather than beach and ski towns. It does not mean nature markets are dead. It means you have to buy them at the right price.

4. Regulation is splitting in two

Cities keep tightening. Cleveland adopted a 10% density cap that takes effect in late November 2026, and a federal appeals court upheld New Orleans’ one-permit-per-block rule in August 2026. At the same time, several states are pulling authority back: Indiana’s House Bill 1210, effective July 2026, bars cities and counties from capping the number of rental properties. In 2027 the rules can differ completely between two towns twenty minutes apart, so regulation has to be the first screen, not the last.

5. Nature is the demand engine

Travelers are choosing parks, trails, water and quiet. Airbnb named nature its top-booked experience category and saw national park searches jump 35%. Great Smoky Mountains alone drew more than 11.5 million visits in 2025. Rural and small-city listings are also where supply is still growing, up 5.3% in August and September 2026 while urban listings fell, so the best nature markets will be the ones where demand is outrunning that new supply.

What AirDNA’s 2026 rankings tell us

AirDNA published two investment rankings in 2026, and both point the same way.

RankJanuary 2026 Best Places to InvestMain demand driver
1Port Arthur, TexasRefining, shipping and LNG construction
2Abilene, TexasAir Force base, data centers, healthcare
3Downtown Saint Paul, MinnesotaGovernment, hospitals, events
4Charleston, West VirginiaGovernment and healthcare
5Springfield, IllinoisState government
6Lake Charles, LouisianaPetrochemical and port
7Montgomery, AlabamaGovernment and military
8Akron, OhioHealthcare and universities
9Lebanon, PennsylvaniaRegional and workforce travel
10Jackson, MississippiGovernment and healthcare

Across the top 10, AirDNA reported an average home price near $296,000 and gross yields near 14%. AirDNA excluded markets with primary-residence-only rules or on-site host mandates before ranking.

In September 2026 AirDNA followed with 17 smaller hidden-gem submarkets, led by Rockford, Illinois, Akron, Ohio and Warner Robins, Georgia. Each had 400 to 1,000 listings, an estimated yield above 10% and a small share of professionally managed properties.

The lesson is not that everyone should buy in Port Arthur. It is that the math in 2027 rewards a low price relative to income and steady, year-round demand. You can find both of those near nature too. You just have to look harder.

Our own read: 5,076 homes for sale, marketed as rentals

Ideal Location tracks homes listed for sale that are marketed as short-term rentals across the country. Our August 2026 snapshot covered 5,076 active listings. For each one we compared the listing’s estimated annual rental revenue to its asking price. That ratio is called gross yield.

Read these numbers carefully. Gross yield is revenue divided by price, before cleaning, platform fees, utilities, insurance, taxes, management, maintenance and your mortgage. Revenue figures are listing-level estimates, not audited results, and small samples swing. Use them to decide where to look, not what to buy.

By state: where the price-to-revenue math is strongest

StateListingsMedian priceMedian est. revenueMedian gross yield
Pennsylvania132$369,000$52,48414.9%
South Carolina120$417,000$56,33414.7%
Alabama88$457,500$53,61814.5%
Ohio73$415,000$56,33014.2%
Michigan75$359,900$49,52014.0%
Missouri66$279,950$34,76613.9%
Florida850$550,000$65,89912.7%
Tennessee611$629,999$65,58710.9%
North Carolina226$574,500$57,51010.7%
Colorado156$699,000$66,5219.6%
Montana235$1,275,000$98,0028.1%

Ideal Location analysis of active for-sale listings marketed as short-term rentals, August 2026. States with at least 40 listings; selected rows shown.

The pattern matches AirDNA’s. The famous mountain states, Montana, Idaho, Colorado and Oregon, sit at the bottom on yield because prices have run far ahead of revenue. The Northeast, Midwest and Southeast, where a good cabin or lake house still costs well under $500,000, sit at the top.

Nature-based markets in our data

MarketListingsMedian priceMedian gross yieldThe draw
Branson, Missouri14$212,50015.8%Ozark lakes and shows
Gulf Shores, Alabama26$707,00015.7%Gulf beaches and state park
Tobyhanna, Pennsylvania26$338,75015.1%Poconos lakes and forest
Orange Beach, Alabama10$542,45015.1%Gulf beaches
Joshua Tree, California17$598,00015.0%Joshua Tree National Park
Yucca Valley, California13$498,00013.5%High desert, park gateway
Bryson City, North Carolina6$587,00012.5%Smokies, rivers, rail
Blue Ridge, Georgia34$699,45012.5%North Georgia mountains
Sedona, Arizona10$874,45012.0%Red rock trails
Gatlinburg, Tennessee95$650,00012.0%Great Smoky Mountains
Sevierville, Tennessee247$689,00011.1%Great Smoky Mountains
Broken Bow, Oklahoma80$599,0009.9%Beavers Bend, lake cabins
Big Bear Lake, California8$675,0007.6%Mountain lake, skiing
Whitefish, Montana120$1,399,0007.2%Glacier National Park gateway
Asheville, North Carolina12$762,0007.0%Blue Ridge Mountains

Ideal Location analysis, August 2026. Markets with at least five active listings. Small samples; confirm with current comps.

The 2027 rate test: what gross yield do you need?

Here is the most useful number in this guide. Most debt service coverage ratio (DSCR) lenders divide a property’s expected gross rental income by its annual mortgage payment, taxes and insurance. A ratio of 1.0 means the rent covers the payment. Many lenders give their best pricing at 1.25 or higher.

We ran the math at 2027 conditions: 20% down, a 30-year loan, about 1.8% of the price a year for taxes and insurance, and DSCR rates that typically sit one to three points above conventional investment loans.

Loan rateGross yield for DSCR 1.0Gross yield for DSCR 1.25Gross yield to cash-flow after 40% operating costs
7.5%8.5%10.6%about 14.2%
8.0%8.8%11.1%about 14.7%
8.5%9.2%11.5%about 15.3%

Ideal Location calculation. The same percentages hold at any price, because payment and income both scale with price. Lender methods vary, and some discount projected short-term rental income.

Read that last column twice. Getting a loan approved and actually making money are different tests. At 2027 rates, a property needs a gross yield in the mid teens to cover its operating costs and its mortgage from rental income alone. That is roughly where AirDNA’s top markets sit, and it is why so many beautiful mountain towns with 7 to 9% yields only work for buyers putting much more than 20% down or buying mainly for personal use.

Ideal Location’s 2027 shortlist

Combining the national trends, AirDNA’s rankings and our own listing data, these are the kinds of nature-based markets we would look at first in 2027.

  • The Poconos, Pennsylvania. A short drive for tens of millions of people in the New York and Philadelphia metros, lakes and forest in every direction, and prices that still let the math work. Tobyhanna-area listings in our data had a median yield above 15%.
  • The Hi-Desert, California. Joshua Tree, Yucca Valley and Twentynine Palms sit at the gate of a national park and draw a design-minded, photography-driven guest who will pay for a distinctive stay. Permits and county rules are the gating question.
  • The Smokies, Tennessee and North Carolina. The most visited national park in the country, a deep and proven rental market, and enough inventory to buy well. Choose carefully: supply is heavy, so the view, the hot tub and the reviews decide who wins.
  • The North Georgia mountains. Blue Ridge and Ellijay pair a drive-to market from Atlanta with rivers, trails and lakes, at yields still in the low teens.
  • The Gulf Coast of Alabama. Gulf Shores and Orange Beach showed some of the strongest yields in our data, with the caveat that coastal insurance costs must be underwritten line by line.
  • The Ozarks, Missouri. Branson’s entry prices are among the lowest in our data for a true lake-and-hills destination.

Every one of these markets has its own permit rules, taxes and neighborhood restrictions. We keep a database of more than 72,000 U.S. jurisdictions and their short-term rental posture, and our Sedona market report shows what a full local analysis looks like.

Where to be careful in 2027

  • High-price mountain towns where yields sit in the single digits. They can still be wonderful places to own, but they rarely pay for themselves from rental income at today’s rates.
  • Cities that have adopted density caps, primary-residence rules or permit lotteries. A permit that does not transfer at sale can erase a property’s rental value overnight.
  • Markets where new listings are growing faster than demand. AirDNA flagged double-digit supply growth even in some of its favored smaller markets, which can squeeze occupancy quickly.

How to screen any address in 2027

  1. Rules first. Confirm the property can legally be rented by the night today and after you buy it, including permits, HOA rules and whether permits transfer.
  2. Revenue second. Pull at least a dozen true comparables. Our STR Rentalizer gives a first read on revenue, occupancy and nightly rate.
  3. Run the yield test. Divide expected annual revenue by price. Below about 9% will be hard to finance at 20% down. Below about 14% will not fully cover costs and the mortgage from rent alone.
  4. Check seasonality. A market that earns half its year in ten weeks needs reserves and a plan for the slow months.
  5. Price the operating costs. Cleaning, platform fees, utilities, insurance, property taxes, maintenance and management typically take 35 to 45% of revenue.
  6. Plan the financing and the team. See our Superhost funding guide for the options, and find a vacation rental manager if you will not self-manage.

Ask us to screen a market or an address

Questions people ask

Is 2027 a good year to buy a vacation rental?

For the right property, yes. Supply growth has slowed sharply and AirDNA expects demand, occupancy and pricing to strengthen through 2027. The challenge is financing cost, so the purchase price relative to revenue matters more than in any year since 2021.

What is a good gross yield for a short-term rental in 2027?

At 20% down and investor loan rates around 7.5 to 8.5%, roughly 9% gets you to a 1.0 DSCR, about 11% to 1.25, and about 14 to 15% to cover operating costs and the mortgage from rental income alone.

Why are the top-ranked markets not beach or ski towns?

Because rankings like AirDNA’s weigh revenue against purchase price. Workforce and mid-size markets combine steady demand with low prices. Famous resort towns often have strong revenue but even stronger prices.

Are nature-based vacation rentals still worth it?

Demand for nature is rising, not falling, with national park searches up sharply and record visitation at many parks. The opportunity is in nature markets where prices have not run ahead of revenue, and in properties distinctive enough to command a premium rate.

When will the 2027 market rankings come out?

AirDNA has released its Best Places to Invest report in late January in recent years. We will update this guide with the new rankings and a fresh read of our own listing data.

Thinking about building rather than buying? See Ideal Location Reflections, our modern prefab cabin program for land you already own, or read how the pieces fit together in the Ideal Location ecosystem.

Sources